Human Hair Crochet Braids vs Synthetic Crochet Braids: Which Should You Choose?

Scrolling through endless crochet braids options and feeling totally overwhelmed? Let’s break down the real differences between human and synthetic crochet braids — so you can pick wisely and slay your protective style game.

The Quick Breakdown: Human Hair vs Synthetic

When to Choose Human Hair Crochet Braids

You love switching up your look: straighten, curl, apply heat, or even color — human hair handles it.

You want a natural, seamless blend that makes people think it’s all your real hair.

You see your style lasting several weeks (or even months) and want maximum value.

You’re in a setting (work, formal events) where authenticity matters.

You care about scalp health and premium quality.

Pro tip: With human hair, your care routine is key. Use sulfate‑free shampoo, deep condition, seal the ends, and wear satin/silk at night.

Coilycuehair's 100% Human Hair Pre-looped Boho Braids are the gold standard here. Ethically sourced, hand-braided, and designed to last - they're worth every penny.
🛍️ Shop our Human Hair Boho Braids Collection: Coilycue Human Hair Crochet Extensions

When Synthetic Crochet Braids Make Sense

You’re on a tight budget but still want to protect your hair.

You like frequent changes—synthetic is good for quick swaps.

You love fun colors (purple, pink, ombré)—synthetic has them ready to go.

You prefer a low‑maintenance style you mostly “set and forget.”

You’re doing a very short‑term protective style, e.g. for an event or vacation.

The Real Cost Breakdown of Synthetic vs Human Hair

Synthetic install: $20–$60 (3–5 weeks) → ~ $260–$520/year

Human hair install: $80–$200 (6–8+ weeks) → ~ $240–$400/year including refreshes and multiple installs

So yes — high quality human hair can cost less over time while giving you far more flexibility.

Synthetic vs Human Hair Maintenance Reality Check

Human Hair Crochet Braids

Treat them like your own hair: shampoo, condition, moisturize, detangle gently, protect at night. With care, they can look fresh for a long time.

Synthetic Crochet Braids

Wash gently and sparingly (mild shampoo, cold water). Never use heat. Expect more frizz and tangling over time.

⚠️ Health & Safety Considerations (Very Important)

Recent tests of popular synthetic braiding hair brands found volatile organic compounds (VOCs), heavy metals, and even benzene in them. 
These chemicals could pose risks through skin contact, inhalation (e.g. when sealing with hot water or “singing” ends), or even ingestion if tiny fibers break off. 

While more study is needed, it’s something to seriously consider when choosing synthetic over human hair.

Which Should You Pick?

Go for Human Hair If:

• You want maximum styling freedom

• You value natural appearance & longevity

• You see hair as an investment, not a disposable piece

• You’re in environments where “prestige” or authenticity matters

Opt Synthetic If:

• Budget is your main concern

• You enjoy frequent changes & experimentation

• You want ready colors

• You need a temporary protective style

FAQ

Are human hair crochet braids better than synthetic?
A: Human hair crochet braids look more natural, last longer, and can be styled with heat. Synthetic crochet braids are more affordable but usually don’t last as long.

How long do human hair crochet braids last?
A: With proper maintenance, human hair crochet braids can last 6–8 weeks or longer, making them a great investment for protective styling.

Can you wash crochet braids made with synthetic hair?
A: Yes, but synthetic crochet braids are more prone to tangling and frizz when washed. Human hair crochet braids handle washing much better and refresh easily.

Which type of crochet braids is more affordable?
A: Synthetic crochet braids are generally cheaper upfront, but human hair crochet braids may save money in the long run since they last longer and can be reused.

Do human hair crochet braids feel lighter than synthetic?
A: Yes, human hair crochet braids tend to be lighter and softer, while synthetic hair can feel heavier and stiffer on the scalp.

Can I style human hair crochet braids with heat?
A: Yes! Human hair crochet braids can be curled, straightened, or even colored. Synthetic crochet braids typically cannot withstand heat styling.

Is synthetic hair safe?
A: Some synthetic hair products contain chemicals that may pose risks (VOC emissions, heavy metals). Always cleanse new synthetic hair before installing, consider more natural or human options if sensitivity is a concern.

Final Thought

If your goal is a long‑lasting, natural look that you can style freely, human hair crochet braids are the superior pick. But if your main concern is budget or trying fun colors for a few weeks, synthetic can work — just know its limitations.

Ready to Upgrade Your Protective Style Game?

If you're ready for crochet braids hair that looks natural, lasts longer, and gives you complete styling freedom, it's time to invest in quality.

Shop Coilycue's Human Hair Crochet Braids Collection and experience the difference premium human hair crochet braids make. Your hair deserves the best, and these crochet braids extensions deliver on both style and longevity.

Stop settling for synthetic when you can have the real thing that actually saves you money in the long run!